Stephenson House: Swan Lake, NY

About The Property

It’s tempting to begin with the long list of amenities offered at the Stephenson House—heated pool, tennis court, wine cellar, and a stunning guest house, to name a few—but the true appeal of this 20-acre Catskills estate lies in the gracious, grounded lifestyle it fosters. This is a place where heritage architecture and modern sensibility intertwine, where one can recharge in solitude or host with ease, and where every detail—from the romantic turret of the 1890s Victorian to the restorative rhythm of open meadows and stone walls—adds up to something much greater than the sum of its parts.

The main residence is a fairytale vision with its sunshine-yellow exterior, intricate period trim, and signature Victorian allure. A broad covered porch wraps the home in classic country charm and invites morning coffee and leisurely chats. Inside, warmth and craftsmanship abound—from the honed granite counters in the chef’s kitchen to the custom stone fireplace built from rock quarried on-site. Smaller, functional spaces add convenience and character: a walk-in pantry, a spacious mudroom with utility sink, and a stone-lined hallway that leads to a cozy, romantic wine room tucked into the home’s original foundation.

Upstairs, the sun-drenched primary suite is a peaceful retreat with double pedestal sinks and a clawfoot tub nestled into a bay window overlooking the grounds. Three additional bedrooms in the main house offer plenty of space for family or guests, while original hardwood floors and generous windows maintain a connection to the land throughout.

The lifestyle enhancements continue with the 1,700-square-foot guest house, featuring a dramatic yoga studio with soaring ceiling and expansive picture windows. There is also a one bedroom apartment, complete with kitchenette, spacious living room, and glass sliders opening onto pretty, landscaped patios. Situated beside the large heated swimming pool, and with an outdoor shower, it does double duty as a pool house.

A restored 2,500-square-foot barn includes climate-controlled storage and working farm features like a chicken coop and animal stalls, ideal for keeping goats, donkeys, llamas, or simply fulfilling your agrarian dreams. Open fields invite horseback riding, hiking, and ATV adventures. There’s even a tennis court tucked neatly into the landscape.

Established fruit trees and organic gardens support a sustainable way of living, while the nearby hamlets of Jeffersonville and Narrowsburg offer fine dining, delightful shops, farmers’ markets, fly fishing and hiking. And just down the road is Bethel Woods Performing Arts Center, where the spirit of the legendary Woodstock Festival still lingers.

Whether as a personal retreat or a family compound, the Stephenson House is a true legacy property—authentic, inspiring, and ready to embark on its next chapter.

Listing Agent: Jennifer Grimes, 845-593-9524