Heinle Homestead: Swan Lake, NY

 

Open House: Saturday, November 21, 11-2

About The Property

For those seeking flexibility and opportunity with their country home, Heinle Homestead is a unique offering featuring two renovated homes on one 15 acre lot.

Sited at the top of a hill with long range southerly views, and a mix of rolling lawn, meadow and woods, Heinle Homestead is a turnkey compound ready for myriad options: investment, multi-generational living, house hacking, or anything else that two fully functional homes can afford.

The main home is a fully renovated, 1650 square foot 3 bed, 2 bath home. Updated extensively in 2025, the house features new windows, a new roof, and new utilities as well as a full cosmetic upgrade.

Entering through the rear courtyard of the home, a vaulted kitchen and dining room combination makes for an impressive greeting. Ample storage, stainless appliances, quartzite counters, and a significant picture window define the kitchen’s compelling blend of form and function.

To the opposite side of the central staircase, a 10 person dining room is ready for large scale hosting or a quiet morning coffee. The space feels airy yet contained - a welcome combination for a dining room.

Down the hall towards the living room is the first full bathroom featuring a shower and a stacked washer dryer. The hall continues and opens in to a serene and spacious living room.

Three walls of windows and a main southern exposure means this space feels sun-soaked throughout the day. Enjoy the warmth and functionality of the Jotul gas stove that turns on and off with the press of a button. The space feels naturally divided between a fire facing lounge and a tv area but could be configured in a number of ways to best suit your needs. Just off the living room is the downstairs queen bedroom.

Upstairs, the remaining two bedrooms and bath are to be found. Both bedrooms are spacious, easily accommodating a King bed and additional furniture. Skylights keep the spaces light and bright throughout the day, and allow for some in-bed stargazing on a clear night. The upstairs full bath features a skylight, as well as a tub/shower combo.

To the other side of the property, you’ll find the additional 800 square foot, 2 bed, 1 bath house. Updated in 2020, the home is fully functional with a full kitchen as well as a full bathroom with standing shower and stacked washer dryer. This is more than just an ADU - this is a rentable home if you desire, or a wonderful “in-law” option for visits or more permanent multi-generational living. If neither of those make sense for your needs, this could also be a fantastic studio or workspace. The flexibility that this building affords can’t be overstated.

Outside, the grounds stretch out around the two homes with a large yard on all sides. The ground is level enough for pools, gardens, sport courts or the like - and significant enough for a hobby farm or small scale agriculture if that’s more your speed. Ultimately, like most things with Heinle Homestead, flexibility is the name of the game.

Located centrally in Sullivan County, Heinle Homestead is under 15 minutes from hot spots like Livingston Manor, Jeffersonville, and Bethel Woods Center for the Arts - and just under 25 from Callicoon. Liberty and Monticello are also only 10 and 20 minutes away respectively with their myriad services. This is a wonderful launching pad for the best of what this area has to offer, and with all of its many possibilities - Heinle Homestead is a unique offering with so many fun possibilities.

*Agent discloses interest in property.

64 heinle rOAD
swan lake ny 12783

DETAILS

MAIN HOUSE:

  • Bedrooms: 3

  • Bathrooms: 2

  • Square feet: 1,650

  • Built: 1920

  • Renovated: 2025

  • Heat: heat pump, electric baseboard, propane stove

  • Fuel: propane

  • Water heater: electric, standalone

  • Roof: Shingle (2025)

  • Basement: unfinished

GUEST HOUSE:

  • Bedrooms: 2

  • Bathrooms: 1

  • Square feet: 800

  • Renovated: 2020

  • Heat: heat pump, electric baseboard

  • Fuel: electric

  • Water heater: electric, standalone

  • Roof: shingle

  • Basement: crawl

  • Acres: 14.95

  • Water: well

  • 2 detached garages, (2 car and 1 car)

  • Cell service: fair

  • Internet: Spectrum

  • School district: Liberty

  • Town: Liberty

  • County: Sullivan

  • SBL: 43.-1-10.1

  • Taxes: Town/Co: $3,911 ; School: $4,481

  • Listing price: $635,000

  • Buyer's broker compensation: 2%

 
 
 
JD Gluckstern
LISTING AGENT
Jared 'JD' Gluckstern

VIEW OTHER COUNTRY HOUSES